‘Thorough inquiry’ says Supreme Court on Pegasus hack

Court rejects government’s excuse of national security

57
Supreme Court on Pegasus
Supreme Court on Pegasus hack says thorough inquiry photo indiatoday.in

Making Clear that the state cannot get “a free pass every time the spectre of ‘national security is raised,” the Supreme Court on 27 October 2021, ordered a thorough inquiry into allegations of unauthorized surveillance using the Israelin MOS’ Pegasus spyware.

The Court said that the investigation will be carried out by a three-member technical committee appointed by the court. Justice RV Raveendran, a former Supreme Court judge, will direct its operations, aided by two other specialists. The committee has been directed to complete the investigation and submit its report to the Supreme Court as soon as possible. The case is to be re-heard after eight weeks.

Ruling on a batch of 12 petitions which sought an independent probe into the alleged illegal use of the Israeli NSO Group spyware Pegasus, the bench of Chief Justice NV Ramana, Justices Surya Kant and Hima Kohli said, ‘The petitioners have placed on record certain material that prima facie merits consideration by this court. There has been no specific denial of any of the facts averred by the Petitioners by the Respondent – Union Of India. There has only been an omnibus and vague denial in the ‘limited affidavit’ filed by the Respondent – Union Of India, which cannot be sufficient. In such circumstances, we have no option but to accept the prima facie case made out by the Petitioners to examine the allegations made.” (Reported in The Indian Express.)

Press reports on the order include those of mainstream dailies such as the The Hindu – ‘The Supreme Court order instituting an independent probe into the possible use of Israeli spyware Pegasus is an effective intervention to protect citizens from unlawful surveillance and a stern rebuff to the Government’s attempt to cover up the issue by using the bogey of ‘national security. It was clear from day one, following the revelations that nearly 300 of some 50,000 phone numbers allegedly identified for surveillance belonged to Indians, that the Government would choose to brazen it out rather than hold or facilitate a credible inquiry.’

During the hearing, the Centre had filed a brief affidavit ‘unequivocally’ denying the allegations against it and said the matter involved national security questions. It did not wish to put the details in a public affidavit and make it a matter of public debate. It said it would divulge the details to a committee of experts who would examine the issue. It urged the court to allow it to set up the committee.

But the bench, in its order, said it is turning down the Government’s request to allow it to set up the committee due to allegations that the Union or state governments are parties to the rights’ deprivations of citizens. It said allowing the request “would violate the settled judicial principle against bias, i.e., that ‘justice must not only be done but also be seen to be done.”

Supreme Court key fundamental imperatives

The Supreme Court underlined the three key imperatives – the right to privacy of citizens, freedom of the press, including journalists’ right to ensure the protection of their sources, and the limits of national security as an alibi by the Government to block disclosure of facts related to citizens rights. The three-judge bench flagged that its intervention is to ‘uphold the constitutional aspirations and the rule of law without being consumed in political rhetoric.’

On the governments refusal to file a detailed response to the allegations made by the petitioners, the court cited the 2011 landmark ruling on black money in Ram Jethmalani vs Union of India to say the government ‘should not take an adversarial position when the fundamental rights of the citizens are at threat.’

“This free flow of information from the petitioners and the state in a writ proceeding before the court is an important step towards Governmental transparency and openness, which are celebrated values under our constitution,” the court is quoted as having said in a report by The Indian Express.

2023 promises an interesting ride for print in India

Indian Printer and Publisher founded in 1979 is the oldest B2B trade publication in the multi-platform and multi-channel IPPGroup. While the print and packaging industries have been resilient in the past 33 months since the pandemic lockdown of 25 March 2020, the commercial printing and newspaper industries have yet to recover their pre-Covid trajectory.

The fragmented commercial printing industry faces substantial challenges as does the newspaper industry. While digital short-run printing and the signage industry seem to be recovering a bit faster, ultimately their growth will also be moderated by the progress of the overall economy. On the other hand book printing exports are doing well but they too face several supply-chain and logistics challenges.

The price of publication papers including newsprint has been high in the past year while availability is diminished by several mills shutting down their publication paper and newsprint machines in the past four years. Indian paper mills are also exporting many types of paper and have raised prices for Indian printers. To some extent, this has helped in the recovery of the digital printing industry with its on-demand short-run and low-wastage paradigm.

Ultimately digital print and other digital channels will help print grow in a country where we are still far behind in our paper and print consumption and where digital is a leapfrog technology that will only increase the demand for print in the foreseeable future. For instance, there is no alternative to a rise in textbook consumption but this segment will only reach normality in the next financial year beginning on 1 April 2023.

Thus while the new normal is a moving target and many commercial printers look to diversification, we believe that our target audiences may shift and change. Like them, we will also have to adapt with agility to keep up with their business and technical information needs.

Our 2023 media kit is ready, and it is the right time to take stock and reconnect with your potential markets and customers. Print is the glue for the growth of liberal education, new industry, and an emerging economy. We seek your participation in what promises to be an interesting ride.

– Naresh Khanna

Subscribe Now

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here