Düsseldorf Appeal Court rejects Nazdar appeals and confirms judgments in Fujifilm’s favor

Patent infringements legal suit against Nazdar and its German distributor Zaro

102
Fujifilm
Photo - Fujifilm

On 14 November 2019, the Higher Regional Court of Düsseldorf, Germany fully confirmed two judgments issued on 13 September 2018 by the Regional Court of Düsseldorf against Nazdar’s UV inkjet inks 702 and 703 Series and rejected Nazdar’s and its German distributor Zaro’s respective appeals (docket nos. I-15 U 71/18 and I-15 U 72/18).

Rob Fassam, director – R&D at Fujifilm Specialty Ink Systems (FSIS) comments, “I am delighted that the Higher Regional Court in Düsseldorf has confirmed our position and the first instance judgment. This sends a clear message to anyone thinking of infringing our intellectual property”.

In 2017 FSIS had filed suit against Nazdar US and Nazdar UK as well as its German distributor Zaro before the Regional Court Düsseldorf for infringement of its UV ink patents EP 1 803 784 B3 and EP 2 383 314 B3 in Germany by offering its 702 and 703 UV inkjet ink Series claimed to be chemically compatible with the original inks for Océ Arizona and Fujifilm Acuity printers.

The patents protect specific inkjet ink compositions, offering a range of properties including improved flexibility, jetting performance, and adhesion. In the first instance, the Regional Court of Düsseldorf issued injunctions against Nazdar and Zaro. In reaction to FSIS’s patent claims, Nazdar changed the chemical composition of its UV inkjet inks. However, Nazdar continued to
market its UV inkjet inks as 702 and 703 Series, and also further failed to indicate to customers the change in chemical composition in a way that FSIS considered necessary to avoid patent infringement.

Upon appeal by Nazdar or Zaro, the Higher Regional Court of Düsseldorf has fully confirmed the first instance judgment. Nazdar and Zaro, therefore, remain injuncted from the offering, bringing into the market and use of patent infringing UV inkjet inks in the future in Germany and are sentenced to pay damages and render account. Furthermore, the Appeal Court upheld the first decision in that the change in chemical composition of the 702 and 703 Series is not sufficient to avoid infringement if Nazdar continues to market their UV inkjets inks as 702 and 703 Series without sufficient indication of the product change.

Finally, while without prejudice for the nullity proceedings filed by Nazdar against the patents before the German Federal Patents Court in Munich, the Higher Regional Court in Düsseldorf, like the first instance decision, did not follow Nazdar’s invalidity arguments and therefore rejected Nazdar’s motion to stay its decision. Meanwhile and in line with that, with the judgment
of 14 January 2020, the Federal Patent Court has also rejected the first nullity action of Nazdar against EP 1 803 784 B3 and fully upheld the patent (docket no. 3 Ni 2/19). The nullity action against the second patent EP 2 383 314 B3 will be heard on 18 February 2020 (docket no. 3 Ni 5/19). Due to the decision to uphold the first patent, FSIS is confident that the Federal Patents Court will similarly also uphold the second patent.

In the infringement proceedings, the Düsseldorf Appeal Court has not admitted a further appeal against its decision. Nazdar or Zaro may now only file an appeal against this decision of non-admittance within one month after service. However, even in such cases, the judgments remain
enforceable without any further prerequisites. In the nullity proceedings before the Federal Patents Court in Munich, Nazdar may file appeals, but again FSIS is confident that, should such appeal be lodged, it would remain unsuccessful.

Fassam said, “We invest significant time and resource developing new and exciting technology that benefits the inkjet industry. We will continue to protect our investment by filing patents that cover our technology and will take appropriate action against those who infringe.”

2023 promises an interesting ride for print in India

Indian Printer and Publisher founded in 1979 is the oldest B2B trade publication in the multi-platform and multi-channel IPPGroup. While the print and packaging industries have been resilient in the past 33 months since the pandemic lockdown of 25 March 2020, the commercial printing and newspaper industries have yet to recover their pre-Covid trajectory.

The fragmented commercial printing industry faces substantial challenges as does the newspaper industry. While digital short-run printing and the signage industry seem to be recovering a bit faster, ultimately their growth will also be moderated by the progress of the overall economy. On the other hand book printing exports are doing well but they too face several supply-chain and logistics challenges.

The price of publication papers including newsprint has been high in the past year while availability is diminished by several mills shutting down their publication paper and newsprint machines in the past four years. Indian paper mills are also exporting many types of paper and have raised prices for Indian printers. To some extent, this has helped in the recovery of the digital printing industry with its on-demand short-run and low-wastage paradigm.

Ultimately digital print and other digital channels will help print grow in a country where we are still far behind in our paper and print consumption and where digital is a leapfrog technology that will only increase the demand for print in the foreseeable future. For instance, there is no alternative to a rise in textbook consumption but this segment will only reach normality in the next financial year beginning on 1 April 2023.

Thus while the new normal is a moving target and many commercial printers look to diversification, we believe that our target audiences may shift and change. Like them, we will also have to adapt with agility to keep up with their business and technical information needs.

Our 2023 media kit is ready, and it is the right time to take stock and reconnect with your potential markets and customers. Print is the glue for the growth of liberal education, new industry, and an emerging economy. We seek your participation in what promises to be an interesting ride.

– Naresh Khanna

Subscribe Now

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here